|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
|
View Poll Results: Who was the better touring car driver at their peak? | |||
Peter Brock | 30 | 30.30% | |
Jim Richards | 45 | 45.45% | |
Unsure: Both great drivers | 24 | 24.24% | |
Voters: 99. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
27 Oct 2007, 13:19 (Ref:2052646) | #1 | |
Veteran
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 1,123
|
Who was better: Brock or Richards?
Peter Brock or Jim Richards?
I'm looking for a consensus on the better driver during their peak. A reason for the choice is also sought. That would make this thread all the more interesting? |
|
__________________
Mainstream media - your source for lies, deceptions, cover-ups and agendas galore. And let's not mention censorship. |
27 Oct 2007, 14:36 (Ref:2052682) | #2 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 8,782
|
ballbreaker of a question both were brrilliant (even that is an understatment) both had great qualities and did many outstanding drives, in terms of form cards Brock had the most wins on the mountain Richo had the most starts, you could bounce this type of stuff from their whole carrer, so from my perspective as a massive fan of both drivers i can't split them, but proberly the nitty gritty stats man can.
i vote Unsure:both great driver. |
||
|
27 Oct 2007, 23:08 (Ref:2052963) | #3 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2004
Posts: 1,042
|
Great thread.
My vote is for Jum, simply for his versatility, and ability in such a wide range of very different vehicles. No one can challenge Brockie for being the best at the mountain, but for mine, Jim is the best. |
||
__________________
Nothing really worth putting. |
27 Oct 2007, 23:52 (Ref:2052974) | #4 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: Jun 2004
Posts: 91
|
Good as he was, Brock cannot truly be called the King of The Mountain, Richards at least won it in cars he was entered in from the word go. He is also a far more versatile driver and, more importantly, had enough sense to know when to quit. He was also more of a gentleman on and off track and (I know I'm going to get flamed for this) he didn't listen to his own publicity machine.
I know that some of this is outside the purview of the question but so what, sue me. End |
||
__________________
Buzzin' Off The Black Gloved One |
28 Oct 2007, 01:04 (Ref:2052991) | #5 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 1,269
|
I voted for PB, but man, what a question!!!
I think there's a few periods you have to look at. PB and Richo seem to have peaked at differing periods, and for differing lengths. Brock was absolutely untouchable 77-85 for mine. Yes, he didn't have the ATCC results, but I think back to his return to the factory in 78 - He took that junker of an SLR5000 and beat the field at Sandown. Granted he had some of the best pieces of machinery, but still made even his team mates seem ordinary. Richo seems to have peaked from 84 to the early to mid 90's. The BMW arguably was "good", but not as fast as other bits of machinery. He did some great development work on Godzilla, and who can forget him making a mockery of some of NASCAR's stars in Japan in a demonstration run? 2nd in an old lumina - not bad! A good reference point, albeit somewhat redundant in that Richo was just ending what could be his peak, and Brock was winding down, would be the 1996 run in the Volvo. Brock was taking in some somewhat mediocre results, while Jim stepped in and took out the Bathurst 1000 support races. I believe this to be the last time the two were in the same car. Unarguably, both were fantastic till their retirements. If we were to disregard their one off's in the main series in comebacks, Brock came out of his last stint in the lead with the fastest lap, and Richo's last serious run he walked off the podium with Mark Skaife as a winner at Bathurst. Pretty good for some "old geezers". |
||
|
28 Oct 2007, 09:06 (Ref:2053077) | #6 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 8,782
|
Quote:
|
|||
|
28 Oct 2007, 09:25 (Ref:2053090) | #7 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,387
|
There career paths were a bit different. I wouldn't like to nominate one as they were both good.
|
||
__________________
Life is all about Ass. You're either covering it, kissing it, kicking it, laughing it off, busting it or trying to get a piece of it. |
28 Oct 2007, 09:41 (Ref:2053099) | #8 | |
Racer
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 210
|
Jim was and remains a far more complete driver than Brock.
If it comes down to personality as well, then I would put Jim even further ahead. |
|
|
28 Oct 2007, 12:12 (Ref:2053201) | #9 | |
Veteran
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 1,123
|
I recall the first race of the inaugural Group A TCS in 1985 at Sandown, when the track was 3.9km in length. Brock debuted his VK Commodore in Mobil colours. Jim Richards was in his highly fancied JPS BMW 635i (and for those who have trouble remembering, DJ debuted his Green Mustang).
It was a fantastic race. While Brock's VK racer won the race, it should not have won that race. The Commodore's homologated race weight was 1400kg by virtue of it's engine capacity. The 5044cc Commodore V8 car was officially rated at only 308bhp and had a measly 4 speeds. Meanwhile, Richard's car was listed at 1185kg and developed around 285bhp (3.5L 6 cyl) and had a 5 spd gearbox. On a hot day, Brock built up a lead of around 3 sec before Richards began to reel Brock in. Brock's tyres had definitely given off their best. What astounded me during that race was that although Richards was out braking Brock, it was Brock who braked later than Richards. This was so obvious at the end of Sandown's pit straight. Brock ended up winning at the end by a couple of seconds as Richards oversteered, exiting from the back straight. It was a race that Brock should NOT have won given his car disadvantage. It was the only race of the year that Brock won that year but he could have had more wins had he not had rocker failures. Anyway, Jim Richards ended up winning the ch/ship that year. His car cleaned up. It was a beautifully balanced machine and Jim knew how to get the best from it. I reckon 1985 was the year when Jim served notice that he was among the best, most talented drivers around. Although, Brock was considered the best driver at the time, his most successful years were well and truly past him. Still showed glimpses of brilliance but wins were few and far between. Meanwhile, Richards continued to win ch/ships in his M3 (he later joined Brock's Mobil-BMW team when Frank Gardner sold his team to Brock - I can't remember exactly but I think JR was slightly quicker than Brock during that season where the BMWs were winless) and take unlikely wins in his Nissan Skyline against the almost unbeatable Sierras. Brock's 'decline' coincided with Richard's rise. If I had to pick, I'd say Brock was the better, more gifted, driver. When Brock had a competitive car under him he would hardly be sighted by the field, such was his speed. He also raced fair and rarely ever scratched his car. He never used to crash in his prime. He also never ever called the fans a##holes unlike some drivers... he was always willing to sign autographs. A real ambassador for the sport. Both excellent drivers. I love them both. It's a tough call but for me it's the late, great Peter Brock. |
|
|
28 Oct 2007, 12:41 (Ref:2053220) | #10 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Jun 2006
Posts: 210
|
Quote:
I will always rate Jim higher, both as a driver and as a humanbeing. |
||
|
28 Oct 2007, 13:15 (Ref:2053237) | #11 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 432
|
both legends but i picked Brocky
hard choice |
||
__________________
if only Valiants had brakes |
28 Oct 2007, 19:47 (Ref:2053561) | #12 | |
Racer
Join Date: Apr 2006
Posts: 163
|
both are excellent tarmac drivers but brock showed how he could win on various surfaces, the around OZ rally, rallycross and few off road rallys. brock also dappled with openwheelers with some success.So it is Brock for me.
|
|
|
29 Oct 2007, 00:39 (Ref:2053715) | #13 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2006
Posts: 531
|
Tuff one to split.
I went Brock but was probably influenced by heart more than head. Both top notch drivers with their numerous Bathurst wins, ATCC & other titles. (Brock - Redex, Rally. Jim - Targas) I think Jim was a smooth complete driver but for grapping a car, wringing its neck to get the best out of it without breaking it = Brock. A comment in Icons of Australian Sport: Peter Brock (from Phil Brock i think?) about how many times the car broke putting it on the trailer after a race win summed up how far Peter knew he could push a car. Both awesome drivers though ! |
||
__________________
Bite off more than you can chew and then chew like hell. |
29 Oct 2007, 02:48 (Ref:2053741) | #14 | |
Racer
Join Date: Jul 2007
Posts: 398
|
How do you seperate...both very versatile, 'Jum' Winning in everything from Porsches to Nascars and Auscars, as well as his Targa stranglehold. Peter was the same, Redex trials & Rallycrossing to Bathursts, Le Mans and Spa.
At their peak, in equal equipment, both nearly inseperable, even in Wet conditions...it was rare to see either man spin, let alone crash or break the car and both fair sports, that wouldnt punt off to win. Off the track, certainly both characters and each had their own unique persona and a legion of fans in Australia and New Zealand. Together, one of the greatest driving combinations in Australian Racing History. Both true legends of the sport. |
|
|
29 Oct 2007, 03:04 (Ref:2053746) | #15 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Oct 2005
Posts: 458
|
Jim for sure. Brock regularly had the biggest budget, and the best cars in the ATCC. Jim only got these for small windows in his career
|
||
|
29 Oct 2007, 03:30 (Ref:2053753) | #16 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2005
Posts: 626
|
As drivers impossible to pick.In fact if you put sedan driving Brock,Richards,Skaife,Perkins,D.Johnson,Moffat,Grice,Geoghegan,Bartlett and a couple of current lads ,all in their prime in identical cars and raced them 5 heats,the results would be all over the place I'd bet.
As persons of integrity...let he who has never sinned cast the first stone,but Jum's pack of rissoles was priceless. |
|
|
29 Oct 2007, 04:09 (Ref:2053761) | #17 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Jul 2004
Posts: 156
|
Both drivers are great, but i went with Jim Richards.
Mainly because he managed to win Bathurst in Group C, Group A and V8 Supercars. Also he won more ATCC championships than Brock. But with saying that Brock was a naturally gifted driver that nobody can beat when he is in the zone |
||
|
29 Oct 2007, 04:15 (Ref:2053764) | #18 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,182
|
I picked Jim just cause he drove anything and won in it, as prevoiusly said here he won in Group C,A and supertaxis.
Brock was great and specially at the Mount but his versitility was not that to match Jim. Great thread topic. |
||
__________________
2015 V8Supercar Champion #5 PDA Mark Frosty Winterbottom To Finish First, First you must Finish |
29 Oct 2007, 05:01 (Ref:2053772) | #19 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 10,043
|
Quote:
Brock scored pole by virtue of the fact he was one of the very few cars not running round on tyre rations (this affected the likes of JPS & DJR, there was a strike or something. As it was, at Rd 1 at Winton a few weeks earlier, JPS had to give Crichton tyre's which were hardly of the racing variety, while Richards made do with what racing slicks they had), Peter just kept bolting on fresh tyres until he set a quick enough time. In the race, Richards got caught up in the first corner pile-up, putting him 10 or so seconds off Brock from the start. Richards came back through the field, and was on Brocks bumper starting the last lap, before having a half-lose exiting Torana on the last lap. It was actually a race Brock SHOULD have won, considering he was the only front-runner who had a trouble free race (DJ spun off whilst in second). I'm not saying who was better than who, just that that Sandown race isn't a good example for the pro-Brock side. |
|||
__________________
"The Great Race" 22 November 1960 - 21 July 1999 |
29 Oct 2007, 07:07 (Ref:2053802) | #20 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2005
Posts: 1,123
|
Quote:
In fact, I believe you are stretching the truth. There is no way Richards was 10s behind Brock. The gap was never more than 3-4s (albeit I am relying on childhood memory). I reckon you're mistaking JR for DJ who speared off the circuit at the end of pit straight later in the race. I will stand corrected if you can provide proof of the lead deficit. PM me and I will retract my statement if you can provide the video! PS That 3.9km circuit was not V8 friendly. Those esses before Dandenong corner were definitely hard on tyres. Again, Brock should NOT have won, that hot day!!! |
||
|
29 Oct 2007, 07:09 (Ref:2053803) | #21 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,387
|
Quote:
Maybe you should read up on Peter Brock a bit. It's obvious you don't have much of an idea what he did in his career. |
|||
__________________
Life is all about Ass. You're either covering it, kissing it, kicking it, laughing it off, busting it or trying to get a piece of it. |
29 Oct 2007, 07:30 (Ref:2053810) | #22 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,182
|
Quote:
I do know what the King drove over the years pete55, but to me Jim won in nearly everything he drove. |
|||
__________________
2015 V8Supercar Champion #5 PDA Mark Frosty Winterbottom To Finish First, First you must Finish |
29 Oct 2007, 08:09 (Ref:2053822) | #23 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,387
|
And Brock didn't ??????
|
||
__________________
Life is all about Ass. You're either covering it, kissing it, kicking it, laughing it off, busting it or trying to get a piece of it. |
29 Oct 2007, 10:40 (Ref:2053906) | #24 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 4,182
|
Pete it does all come down to personal preference doesn't.
|
||
__________________
2015 V8Supercar Champion #5 PDA Mark Frosty Winterbottom To Finish First, First you must Finish |
29 Oct 2007, 10:53 (Ref:2053919) | #25 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Sep 2003
Posts: 383
|
A pretty hard one to choose in a way as both were great at any one time! I have to choose Brock only because I have been a fan of his forever, and I suppose that tips him in favour from me!
No doubt that Jum was versatile, and he drove a lot of different cars! For the doubters well Brocky did drive a lot of different cars also, Its just they probably drove different cars at the same period, which makes it seem lopsided! To say that Brocky wasnt versatile, well Brocky drove Rallycross, Rallys, Targas, Touring cars, Auscars, Open Wheelers (briefly) Sports sedans, Hillclimbs, 24 HOUR Races overseas at different times and in different cars! Jum drove most of the same but throw in Speedway,and Trucks??,which Brocky didnt drive! Both were versatile, and drove anything with 4 wheels and most of the time they were winners! |
||
__________________
There will only ever be One KING OF THE MOUNTAIN! |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Geoff Richards | Peter Harding | Tributes Forum | 2 | 20 Dec 2005 10:19 |
richards - villeneuve | GreenAdam | Formula One | 53 | 30 Sep 2004 15:22 |
Richards does it again! | Rowdy | Australasian Touring Cars. | 6 | 16 Aug 2004 08:43 |
Richards to Castrol | mtpanorama | Australasian Touring Cars. | 3 | 23 Dec 2001 00:54 |