|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
18 May 2004, 22:20 (Ref:974908) | #1 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 1,753
|
Safer working under Yellow Flags?
Forgive me if any of the following is wrong, or unworkable. I’m interested in your experienced views.
As a driver, my first bash at flag marshalling at Donington a couple of weeks ago, caused me to think about the problem of drivers failing to sufficiently slow under yellows at the scene of an incident. The basic rule of a green at the post following the scene of an incident seems reasonable enough. However, there is a problem, which increases, the closer the incident marshals are to the “green” post. In order to gain an advantage, or protect their position, drivers will be looking for and anticipating the green flag, and accelerating towards it, possibly whilst still having to pass the incident itself. If the post following the incident showed a stationary yellow, there would be no point in doing so. The lead driver could reduce speed significantly, certain in the knowledge that he couldn’t be “jumped” until the next post. The “winding up” could begin after the incident site rather than through it. Would it work? John |
||
__________________
If, as Freddie Mercury claimed, fat bottomed girls make the rocking world go round, isn't it about time that Croydon received some recognition for its contribution to astrophysics? |
19 May 2004, 03:00 (Ref:975058) | #2 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 3,499
|
Re: Safer working under Yellow Flags?
Quote:
Be aware on the second and subsequent passes that things may have changed (recovery vehicles, ambulances etc). Once past the incident, increase to a speed you feel is safe without causing you to shoot past a slower car. Hit the green and its on again - go for it!! |
|||
__________________
The good old days sure seem like a long time ago!! |
19 May 2004, 05:31 (Ref:975102) | #3 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2002
Posts: 1,074
|
Quote:
|
|||
|
19 May 2004, 06:16 (Ref:975119) | #4 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 1,753
|
Evidently not brickkicker - hence my thought
|
||
__________________
If, as Freddie Mercury claimed, fat bottomed girls make the rocking world go round, isn't it about time that Croydon received some recognition for its contribution to astrophysics? |
19 May 2004, 06:25 (Ref:975124) | #5 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 1,753
|
275 GTB4
The problem is that marshals feel that speeds are not reduced sufficiently for them to feel safe working on track. Whilst I agree with the sentiments in your first para, it's not always like that. [B]Once past the incident, increase to a speed you feel is safe without causing you to shoot past a slower car. Hit the green and its on again - go for it!! [\B] Its the "you feel is safe" bit that needs help. If the driver behind does this, he will be accelerating to catch the guy in front. The guy in front speeds up to avoid being caught out at the green and the people further behind are at full tilt to avoid being dropped at the green flag. Just wondered if the extra yellow would move the problem beyond the marshals. |
||
__________________
If, as Freddie Mercury claimed, fat bottomed girls make the rocking world go round, isn't it about time that Croydon received some recognition for its contribution to astrophysics? |
19 May 2004, 07:38 (Ref:975156) | #6 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 582
|
I agree with the sentiment John, however the execution is difficult. I'm playing devils advocate here but as you well know, all us drivers will, of neccessity (because every other driver will) take the minimum notice of yellow flags that it is possible to do. This is not out of disrespect to any marshal but because
a) There is no way to be sure your fellow competitors will slow b) There is no certainty of sanction for an infringement c) The measure of what constitutes slowing is subjective Perhaps we should be utilising readily available technology to measure infringements and change the interpretation from conjecture to absolute. Easily acheived with GPS type logging and a basic analysis system working the laptimes. Last edited by goforit500; 19 May 2004 at 07:39. |
||
|
19 May 2004, 07:47 (Ref:975162) | #7 | |
CCNA
Royalridge Computing A LARGE Teapot Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 10,691
|
Hi john - I see where you're coming from but there are a couple of things that I think would make it unworkable - both for drivers and marshals.
To be honest, the only solution I can see to this problem is better enforcement of driving standards and ensuring that flag rules are obeyed properly. |
|
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire. |
19 May 2004, 08:06 (Ref:975175) | #8 | |
Racer
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 397
|
When I started Marshalling (25+ years ago!!), I'm sure the system johnw is suggesting was actually in use.
However it was changed for exactly the reasons given by Evilpumpkin. "Its common sense" "Do drivers have that?" I know some that do- They used to be Marshals!! |
|
__________________
The last car through is a Rover - Over!! |
19 May 2004, 08:09 (Ref:975176) | #9 | ||
TT Photo Of The Year Winner - 2009 & 2010
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 533
|
Didn't it use to be the case that a stationary yellow was displayed after the waved yellow and before the green in the way that John is thinking about?
I think the practise was changed to just a green following the waved yellow about 15 (or maybe more) years ago, presumably for the reasons that EPW states. |
||
__________________
Don't shop hungry; Don't drive angry. |
19 May 2004, 08:15 (Ref:975179) | #10 | |||
Racer
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 344
|
Quote:
The current system has been in use for at least 35 years, probably much longer. |
|||
__________________
Instruction to all drivers - Black bit - yours, green bit - ours |
19 May 2004, 08:34 (Ref:975194) | #11 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 570
|
The practice of a stationary yellow AFTER the incident was introduced into F1 in the early 70s, and club racing in the UK the year after, I believe. It did not last long for all the valid reasons already given.
|
||
__________________
"When you're racing it's life. Anything before or after is just waiting." Steve McQueen "Growing old is compulsory - growing up is optional." Bob Monkhouse OBE |
19 May 2004, 09:05 (Ref:975219) | #12 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2002
Posts: 788
|
Before moving into Startline/Pits marshalling in the early 80's, I spent nearly 20 years on the bank, many of them flagging. I certainly remember showing a stationary yellow after the incident and before the green flag. I cannot remember when the practice ended, but as EP said, two incidents at the same time could close down a lot of the race, not only at short circuits but at well spaced flagging points such as Brands Hatch GP.
|
||
__________________
According to Julius Caesar, the most civilised people in Britain lived in Kent. - QI Elves. |
19 May 2004, 11:10 (Ref:975310) | #13 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 47
|
If we're trying to improve safety under yellow, I have another suggestion I'd like to try out with the drivers on this forum.
If we had another flag in our arsenal, say luminous orange, which was displayed stationary along with a waved yellow when marshals were trackside, would it make any difference? At the moment there is no indication for a driver when he comes round a corner whether the incident is a piece of debris, a spun car or half dozen marshals on the track. For me (a course marshal) I would feel safer knowing that the drivers have at least been warned that we're on the track - even if they take no notice in terms of speed. |
||
|
19 May 2004, 11:17 (Ref:975320) | #14 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 344
|
Main problem with that is, who holds out the new flag whilst the solo flag marshal is waving the yellow?
If drivers just obeyed the rules ( waved yellow - great danger - be prepared to stop ) then there should be no problem. |
||
__________________
Instruction to all drivers - Black bit - yours, green bit - ours |
19 May 2004, 11:42 (Ref:975348) | #15 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2004
Posts: 606
|
"Main problem with that is, who holds out the new flag whilst the solo flag marshal is waving the yellow?"
probably the same person! not difficult to do.... i've found myself waving 3 flags at once on more than 1 occasion! |
||
__________________
the hard part about playing chicken is knowing when to flinch! |
19 May 2004, 12:04 (Ref:975363) | #16 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Mar 1999
Posts: 344
|
I agree it can be done, but holding a stationary whilst waving another flag invariably results in two not particularly well displayed flags - thus defeating the object of the execise. In any case you need a hand free for any/all of the following - displaying the Oil/White/Red as necessary, as well as writing down the numbers of cars that have not obeyed the rules.
Given some of the flagging you see round the country, there are many so-called flag marshals who seem to have difficulty displaying a single flag visibly, let alone adding in a second flag. |
||
__________________
Instruction to all drivers - Black bit - yours, green bit - ours |
19 May 2004, 12:58 (Ref:975420) | #17 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2002
Posts: 1,350
|
Ok, lets take this to a plausible extreme, single handed flag point at Silverstone with no course/incident marshals to help, say Post 3. Big pile up with multiple cars but track isn't blocked, the incident has dumped oil all over the track before the cars slid off onto the grass. Marshals are in attendance dealing with an injured driver. Safety car is scrambled so how does the single flaggie cope with that lot.
First you've got a waved yellow and a slippery surface flag, marshals in attendance: stationary orange. Safety car in your sector: double waved yellow and SC board to hold. The one thing I haven't got is five arms, make it six cause I'll need the extra to wipe the sweat out my eyes. Do we get the mutant transplants on the NHS or will the MSA pay for private treatment to get the flag marshal fraternity modified in quick time. Maybe we should use the multi armed temple guard from Tomb Raider. Last edited by Chigley; 19 May 2004 at 13:05. |
||
__________________
Ian Chalmers, Maker of circuit flags. |
19 May 2004, 13:05 (Ref:975431) | #18 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: May 2004
Posts: 47
|
OK, perhaps I started this discussion going into too much detail. What I wanted to discuss here was whether or not the idea of a 'marshals on track' indicator system would be of benefit, to drivers and marshals alike.
Flagman already stated the problem "If drivers just obeyed the rules ( waved yellow - great danger - be prepared to stop ) then there should be no problem." Drivers don't tend to slow down and probably never will. What I'm looking to do is to alert them that there are people out there running around - not just large lumps of metal. Whether or not a flag marshal is capable of holding 6,5,4,3,2,1 or no flags is already a problem but would be a discussion for a later stage. |
||
|
19 May 2004, 13:34 (Ref:975461) | #19 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 96
|
i read somewhere that the formula renault guys and girls this year have a light in their cockpit and a beep on the radio for when the saftey car is out. do u think this is working? could it be modified made standard in all clases?
Paul |
||
__________________
I ate all the pies |
19 May 2004, 14:01 (Ref:975487) | #20 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 397
|
Quote:
I feel this would be another imposition on them |
||
__________________
The last car through is a Rover - Over!! |
19 May 2004, 15:13 (Ref:975545) | #21 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 970
|
What about an orange-painted board that could be hung over the tire wall or whatever? Then the only hand you need is to swing it out and then bring it back in.
Just an idea. keke |
||
__________________
******************** CART Volunteer Course Observer Program: Commitment, Dedication, Loyalty. RIP 2003 ******************** |
19 May 2004, 15:17 (Ref:975551) | #22 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,124
|
This is almost funny!
We have a signal for "Marshals On Track" it's called a yellow Flag! Nuff Said! The fact that we dress up in Orange Romper Suits makes it easier to see us!! |
||
__________________
27 Years In Orange |
19 May 2004, 15:41 (Ref:975575) | #23 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2002
Posts: 3,364
|
Quote:
(We did have a stationary yellow after the incident until the 1982 season.) All that we need is for drivers to obey the yellow flag. (All - Who am I kidding. ) Regards Jim Last edited by JimW; 19 May 2004 at 15:43. |
|||
__________________
Life is not safe, just choose where you want to take the risks. |
19 May 2004, 16:40 (Ref:975620) | #24 | ||
Racer
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 321
|
Here is a suggestion that should provoke some reactions.Use the laptiming.If R.C are awear of a yellow flag incident with Marshal in attendance and there is no signifcant drop in lap times say 3 or 4 seconds is is not safe to asumme that drivers are not obaying flags properly.If they fail to slow then give them a penalty like a stop go.If they lose positions and points then drivers may start to slow up a little more.
I have been out to incidents when the yellow has been out for severals laps and cars still mange to lose control even though they are well awear of marshals on track. |
||
__________________
If you can't afford to race,become a Marshal. |
19 May 2004, 16:46 (Ref:975631) | #25 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2002
Posts: 676
|
If we were to have an orange luminus flag to display as well( not a bad idea) we could revert to the same system people had of holding out the defunct black and yellow and the yellows for the incident on the post. They worked then it could work again but a different flag, couldnt it?.
RS |
||
__________________
Heartstart courses are for everyone to learn to save a life. |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
yellow flags | simon drabble | Marshals Forum | 38 | 14 Jun 2005 20:20 |
Yellow Flags in F1 in Spain | CombeMarshal | Marshals Forum | 11 | 9 May 2005 16:59 |
Trulli and Yellow Flags | Asp | Formula One | 10 | 16 Sep 2003 00:29 |
Yellow Flags | FilW | Racers Forum | 33 | 9 Apr 2003 18:01 |
Monty/Yellow Flags: What would you do? | Epsilon | Formula One | 13 | 1 Sep 2001 15:53 |