|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
21 Feb 2004, 17:05 (Ref:881429) | #1 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2001
Posts: 13,000
|
How do you rate Irvine
Continuing the mini-series of threads for rating particualr drivers, I wondered how people saw Irvine's career, 18 months after his final race. Did his driving match his unquestionable outspokenness and subtle humour? Did he deserve more even treatment at Ferrari? Would a better driver have won the 1999 title, or did he do well to get so close?
|
||
|
21 Feb 2004, 17:09 (Ref:881432) | #2 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2003
Posts: 2,147
|
I didn't use to rate him at all. I don't think he lived up to his outspoken comments, as he wasn't very good. True, it was a good performance to just miss the 1999 title, but I do think a better driver would have won it.
|
||
|
21 Feb 2004, 17:12 (Ref:881434) | #3 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 116
|
One of my favourite drivers. I know there are always If's and but's, but hadn't the Ferrari mechanics "lost" a wheel at the Nurburgring, he would have been World Champion.
|
||
__________________
Can't wait for slicks!!! |
21 Feb 2004, 17:53 (Ref:881444) | #4 | ||
Forum Host
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 6,529
|
Eddie Irvine wil probably be remembered for his talking rather than driving... a driver who was quick on his day but should have kept his mouth shut and let the driving do the talking... interesting character because of his comments.
|
||
__________________
A byte walks into a bar and orders a pint. Bartender asks him "What's wrong?" Byte says "Parity error." Bartender nods and says "Yeah, I thought you looked a bit off." |
21 Feb 2004, 18:15 (Ref:881453) | #5 | |
20KPINAL
Join Date: May 2003
Posts: 29,853
|
I always rated Irvine highly as a driver....perhaps too highly for some peoples liking. I always wonder what might have been in 1999 had his engine not blown at Imola, had he not overshot his pitbox at Silverstone, had he not had an unlucky Nurburgring, had he not been turned round by DC at Montreal, had he not slid off at Hungary.........I'm depressing myself now.
Highly talented driver, very under-rated. I put him higher than Rubinho, whom I also quite like. |
|
|
21 Feb 2004, 18:24 (Ref:881464) | #6 | ||
Forum Host
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2003
Posts: 6,529
|
your making me feel like crying knowlesy...
poor Irvine!... |
||
__________________
A byte walks into a bar and orders a pint. Bartender asks him "What's wrong?" Byte says "Parity error." Bartender nods and says "Yeah, I thought you looked a bit off." |
21 Feb 2004, 19:27 (Ref:881488) | #7 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 13,211
|
I was an Eddie fan, and i too put him above Rubens. Just wish that he had the use of the same Ferrari's that Rubens has had since 2000, we would have seen him do more imo.
Eddie seems to be disliked (reading posts about him over the last 2 years on this site) but any driver that can score 14 points finishes out of 16 can't be that bad and i honestly believe that had he not had to play #2 to Michael for the first half of '99 (i.e having to sit behind Michaels ailing car at France when he would easily finished 4th in front of Rafe and Michael) he would have been WDC in '99. As others have mentioned, he was also very outspoken, thats what everyone seems to crave in F1, yet he was often harshly critisized for it (yet when Villeneuve did the same, he was seen as a hero? ) Last edited by Mr V; 21 Feb 2004 at 19:30. |
||
__________________
That's so frickin uncool man! |
21 Feb 2004, 19:57 (Ref:881500) | #8 | ||
Team Crouton
20KPINAL
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 39,925
|
Substantially overrated, IMO. Barrichello was/is considerably better - again, IMO.
|
||
__________________
280 days...... |
21 Feb 2004, 20:01 (Ref:881505) | #9 | |
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 325
|
Very good. Not quite at the top but close.
I didn't always find his statements as amusing as some did - they were too often just bolshiness or cliches (and still are). Which is a pity because when he isn't playing up to his persona he seems a thoughtful, intelligent sort. |
|
|
21 Feb 2004, 20:11 (Ref:881511) | #10 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2000
Posts: 2,739
|
Quote:
As for Irvine, although I quite liked him as a personality I don't rate him as any kind of exceptional talent. Quality driver? Yes! WDC quality? NO! I still believe the only reason Irvine was able to get close to Mika in '99 was because of Mika and the Mclaren teams letting down their guard after Schumacher's accident. They made a greater attempt at losing the championship than Irvine made at trying to win it. |
|||
__________________
A torrential afternoon practice session in Watkins Glen saw Villeneuve out-qualify everyone. By 11 seconds.Scheckter stated: "I scared myself rigid that day, I thought I had to be quickest. Then I saw Gilles's time and - I still don't really understand how it was possible. Eleven seconds !" |
21 Feb 2004, 20:52 (Ref:881539) | #11 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 1,384
|
Irvine....simpley the second best driver in F1.
He was a first rate driver from the lower forumla to F1 a great charecter and a superb overall driver package. Not really fare to say "look X has won more races now" as the teams and kit they use has changed over the years but I genuinly think he was the second best driver in F1. |
||
|
21 Feb 2004, 21:05 (Ref:881547) | #12 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2000
Posts: 2,727
|
Good enough to come close to winning the WDC in a Ferrari.
Faster than Mika Salo when Salo had no experience in the Ferrari. And slower than Mika Salo after Salo had had a few races. So it looks to me as if that Ferrari was the fastest car in 1999, and Irvine was the third best Ferrari driver that season ... |
|
|
21 Feb 2004, 22:16 (Ref:881586) | #13 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2002
Posts: 3,370
|
A walking headline, quintessential "playboy in a red Ferrari", starred in many races for lots of wrong reasons including eating a Senna knuckle sandwich an other gaffes.
|
|
__________________
Holden- How One Legendary Driver Earned Nine Permanent circuits- the life blood of motorsport |
21 Feb 2004, 23:34 (Ref:881610) | #14 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2000
Posts: 1,473
|
I don't rate him terribly high. Fair enough, it wasn't until 1999 that he signed a contract that gave him more "presence" in the Ferrari team. As a complete driver I'd rate no higher than the likes of Panis or Salo. He didn't really win any of his 4 GPs outright. Austria was probably his best, and he wouldn't have won that if DC hadn't knocked MH off at the 2nd corner.
|
|
|
22 Feb 2004, 00:19 (Ref:881630) | #15 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2002
Posts: 5,276
|
Good enough for winning races but not a great. Still, what made him stand out was his personality. Like it or not, F1 needs personalities and not clones.
|
||
__________________
"Many people depend on motor racing for their livelihood, to them it is a business. To me, it is a sport." -Jim Clark |
22 Feb 2004, 00:27 (Ref:881632) | #16 | |||
Team Crouton
20KPINAL
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 39,925
|
Quote:
|
|||
__________________
280 days...... |
22 Feb 2004, 04:47 (Ref:881682) | #17 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,196
|
Any teammate of Schuey's tends to get hurt in the ratings but, under any scrutiny or comparison, Eddie must be regarded as a very good driver.
Look at it this way, he fared as well as Rubens and far better than Johnny Herbert as teammate to MS, and Johnny was, for the most part, very competitive with Hakkinen when they were in the same team. Most people would rate Hakkinen better but it's hard to make that stand up - and there's no way known the Ferrari in 99 was better. Verdict: No MS/AP/AS but most definately an A grader. |
|
__________________
"You can get lucky and win one championship but not two ..." Jamie Whincup. I wonder which person with the initials RK he was referring to. |
22 Feb 2004, 05:25 (Ref:881691) | #18 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,744
|
I think that a lot of people rate him lower because of his outspokeness. A lot of people hate JV for the same reason. If JV hadn't been beaten by Button people wouldn't get to use it as justification to say that his career was a sham. The same thing happened to Irvine. Yes MS is better, but I think Irvine is a bit better than RB.
I think most would say that the '99 Ferrari was slower than the McLaren, yet most give high regard to Mika and little to Irvine. At Jaguar Irvine pulled the car further up the rankings, but no one thought anything of that. To be perfectly honest I found it a bit strange that Irvine gave up driving completely. I think he simply didn't like the extra stuff that what went with being a F1 driver. Maybe it's an ego thing, I don't know. |
||
__________________
No Rotor, No Motor. |
22 Feb 2004, 06:28 (Ref:881708) | #19 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,927
|
I would have liked to see him at Jag alongside Webber last year. They would've definitely got 5th in the Constructor's Championship IMO and it would have been good to see how Webber shaped up against an experienced teammate. I liked Irvine when he was at Ferrari, but at Jag he turned into a bit of a whinger. Which was a shame because he did have some talent which he showed in a dog of a car when he was at Jag in 01 and 02 with those 3 podiums.
|
||
__________________
Part time wingman, full time spud. |
22 Feb 2004, 06:29 (Ref:881711) | #20 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,927
|
Sorry, I meant with those 2 podiums!!!
|
||
__________________
Part time wingman, full time spud. |
22 Feb 2004, 06:45 (Ref:881714) | #21 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2001
Posts: 1,340
|
Quote:
On the other hand, that was very good scholl for all the other drivers' agents so Eddie had it covered in his contract. And finally, to cut the : I can't rate high any driver that extends his contract that dissallows him to fight his teammate. And Eddie is one of them. |
|||
__________________
Let it be |
22 Feb 2004, 08:30 (Ref:881745) | #22 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 605
|
I think he had talent but was more interested in being a playboy then a race car driver held him back from reaching his full potential.
Can't blame him tho if I was in his position I probably would have spent my time on yachts with bikini clad woman rather then concentrating on my fitness & testing too. |
||
__________________
What's this for anyway? |
22 Feb 2004, 08:53 (Ref:881757) | #23 | ||
Team Crouton
20KPINAL
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 39,925
|
A grader? Yes, just about. But I think there were a lot of other drivers about at around the same time who would have done as well in the Ferrari as Irvine. I firmly believe he largely flattered to deceive.... (and I certainly don't rate him anywhere near as highly as Herbert.... )
|
||
__________________
280 days...... |
22 Feb 2004, 09:50 (Ref:881776) | #24 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2001
Posts: 2,083
|
I rate him slightly BEHIND rubhins,mostly because the only time that irvine beat him as a team mate was at a time when RB was under unbelievable pressure just after senna's death.other than that RB slightly beat him.
Or one could say that irvine was a touch slower but was far tougher psycologically. All in all i liked him as a driver EXCEPT for the stupid comments towards the end of his career(the stupid comments at the start of his career were great!lol) And the 99 championship lost? He didn't desrve to win it being as slow as he was (especially at suzuka!!) He would have made an interesting champ (or would it have made him unsufferably bigheaded in later life?) |
||
|
22 Feb 2004, 11:16 (Ref:881801) | #25 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2000
Posts: 5,917
|
Irvine really picked up alot since joining F1. He doesn't look/act serious, but i could really see him getting better towards the end of his stint at Ferrari.
He said he learned alot from Michael, and honestly, he applied what he learned. When he realised that the championship was within grasp, he turned serious and tried to up his game...however sadly, in Suzuka he seem to just want to "depend" on Michael beating Mika. He's a fast driver, a loud mouth and a interesting character. I'd put him in Ralf's class and ahead of DC. Almost the equal of RB. |
||
__________________
Alonso: "McLaren and Williams are also great racing teams, but Ferrari is the biggest one that you can go to." |
Thread Tools | |
Display Modes | |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Web Design Going Rate | PaulSands | Motorsport Art & Photography | 2 | 30 Apr 2004 11:06 |
Please rate my site | f14u | Cool Sites | 3 | 10 Aug 2003 23:03 |
Rate the Rookies | DNQ | ChampCar World Series | 31 | 27 Feb 2003 18:27 |
Who do you rate? Checa or OJ? | asha | Bike Racing | 13 | 5 Feb 2003 07:39 |
Rate TV coverage!! | 43Fan | NASCAR & Stock Car Racing | 12 | 26 Nov 2001 13:40 |