|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
31 Jul 2011, 17:45 (Ref:2934096) | #1 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2001
Posts: 13,211
|
Should it be top 4 not top 3?
Just looking at the Championship standings after todays race and was surprised to see that Jenson is only 12 points behind Lewis. Now, considering the tyre problem that he had at Silverstone and Hydraulic problem at Nurburgring, neither of which were his fault then only a 12 point deficit is incredible imo.
Considering this and also considering that (no matter what order we'd personally put them in) Lewis is one of the top 3 drivers and many saying a gap to Jenson, Mark, Felipe, shouldn't we now consider the top 4, not top 3? Jenson has showed (in 2009) that he can win in the dry, it's just that he excels in the slippery wet/dry conditions, but is this enough to put him as a "top" driver? Thoughts? |
||
__________________
That's so frickin uncool man! |
31 Jul 2011, 17:56 (Ref:2934104) | #2 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2000
Posts: 11,402
|
I think so yes he has proved that he is one of the very best. McLaren would never have signed him otherwise IMHO...
|
||
|
31 Jul 2011, 18:07 (Ref:2934113) | #3 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2007
Posts: 1,355
|
Quote:
|
||
|
31 Jul 2011, 18:40 (Ref:2934132) | #4 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2010
Posts: 1,223
|
I would say Vettel and Alonso are the top 2. Then Hamilton, then Button. Jenson is very good when conditions go from wet to dry or the other way around. In full wet weather I think Hamilton has the edge on him. Plus in qualifying and in a badly balanced car I think Hamilton can out perform him.
Vettel overtook Alonso today. Jury is still out, on whether he can race in traffic though. |
|
|
31 Jul 2011, 18:47 (Ref:2934137) | #5 | ||
Ten-Tenths Hall of Fame
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 8,408
|
Yes.
|
||
|
31 Jul 2011, 19:05 (Ref:2934144) | #6 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2005
Posts: 1,027
|
Button's a class act without doubt. I agree, top 4.
|
||
|
31 Jul 2011, 19:31 (Ref:2934153) | #7 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2006
Posts: 5,493
|
It won't be a popular view but still think there's a Top 2 (Alonso & Hamilton), then perhaps a second tier (Vettel and Button).
|
|
|
31 Jul 2011, 19:58 (Ref:2934164) | #8 | |
Retired
20KPINAL
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 22,897
|
Button also had a KERS failure in the Valencia race. So maybe that's his three bits of bad luck out of the way?
Where are we off the next? Oh, yes. Spa! Scene of Button's early retirement due to no fault of his own in last seasons race there. |
|
|
31 Jul 2011, 20:39 (Ref:2934188) | #9 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2005
Posts: 1,981
|
Consider this....
There have been three teams who have won Grand Prix this year - Red Bull, McLaren and Ferrari. So in simple terms, on the day, their (and I mean the team) cars have been good enough. However, the only winning drivers have been Vettel, Hamilton, Button and Alonso. No Webber or Massa wins - so far at least. Today Button 'raced' against Hamilton and beat him, incidentally winning the race at the same time. I don't believe Button has the aggressive edge that maybe is the difference between him and Hamilton. He doesn't go for 50/50 overtake chances for example. I don't believe he is as able, or more probably, as willing, to push his car beyond the limits that he is comfortable with - but he does tend to stay on track, not spin, avoid contact with other cars..... But I do rate him as great in judging the grip levels available to him and pushing the car he has under him right up to that limit. He has proved that on many occasions, not just today, and he is also pretty hot when it comes to tyre choices/strategies/pit stop timing. Hence his obvious prowess in changing weather conditions. I think this puts him right up there on the first tier with Vettel, Alonso and Hamilton and I don't think it is really possible to split their abilities and skill levels by more than half a gnats cock. Anything he lacks in what could be called aggression I think he makes up for with what might be called intelligence. OK - I have said my piece! |
|
|
31 Jul 2011, 21:13 (Ref:2934207) | #10 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 8,885
|
Interesting that one or two have suggested there's a top four that further breaks down into a top two, but put different drivers in that top two.
I agree it's now a top four. If there's a further divide, I think I'd put Vettel and Alonso in the top tier with Button and Hamilton (very) close behind. I don't think we should underestimate Alonso's achievement in gaining consistent podium finishes with that Ferrari. Nor should we dismiss Vettel as a one hit wonder until he's had chance to prove otherwise. |
||
__________________
"Never pick a fight with an ugly person, they've got nothing to lose." |
31 Jul 2011, 22:58 (Ref:2934234) | #11 | ||||
Ten-Tenths Hall of Fame
Veteran
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 8,408
|
Quote:
Quote:
As for Vettel, he's very close to becoming a two hit wonder and it won't be at the last race of the season this year. |
||||
|
31 Jul 2011, 23:52 (Ref:2934248) | #12 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2011
Posts: 1,157
|
Some of you will hate my comparison, but I don't think Button is even close to Hamilton. Or Vettel or Alonso, in fact I rate Webber higher than Button as well.
If you take away all the incidents and tough luck Hamilton has had this year, he'd probably be a long way ahead of Button in points. Same thing last year. I'm not a fan of either driver, so no bias there. In dry conditions, Hungary would have been Hamilton vs Vettel. Button's been up to over a second a lap slower than Hamilton on a number of occasions this year and when things go right for Hamilton, Button isn't close. When Button can start winning on a dry track in a non-dominant car, maybe i'll be proven wrong. But he's yet to do this in his career. Here's the breakdown: Button's maiden win was in the wet at Hungary. We all remember that race, it was a fantastic drive, probably his best ever. The 2 years following his best result was a 5th! Then in 2009 came the dominant Brawn which gave him 6 wins, 2 of which were wet. His 2010 wins; Australia in the same wet-drying conditions and only after Vettel retired from the lead, and China which was another wet race where Hamilton probably should have won but got caught napping. Then 2011 two wet-drying race wins. Button is great at driving in these wet-dry conditions, but take that away and all he has are 4 dry wins to his name in the dominant Brawn. And the strange thing is that I rate Hamilton and Vettel as wet weather specialists, not Button. Give us some heavy rain and Button's advantage is gone. In fact Webber and Alonso aren't too bad in rain either, and Schumacher is one of the best. I can't put Button in the same league as someone like Alonso who has 27 race wins, very few of which would have been wet. |
||
|
1 Aug 2011, 00:51 (Ref:2934260) | #13 | |
Veteran
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 5,702
|
In terms of the best driver out there, I think Alonso and Vettel are clearly one and two... They are the two guys that bring it to the track every single weekend and, no matter what the conditions or adversity, they deliver every race.
They are uncompromising in the consistency of their performances - especially Alonso. After that I would put the two McLaren drivers... Lewis for his incredible natural talent, his aggression, and his ability to grab the car by the scruff of the neck and wrestle speed out of it. Jenson because, while I don't necessarily believe he is the equal of Lewis on talent, no other driver does more with what they have (in terms of talent). For so much of last year when we watched Button struggling to get heat into his tyres, it's somewhat ironic that the very same driving style would pay dividends the following year when the Pirellis were introduced, and brought with them an increased importance on keeping the tyres cool and not over-heating them. I would have Webber just behind the McLaren two - anyone that can run as close as he has done with Vettel throughout their history is pretty good if you ask me. And I would have Kubica probably level with the McLaren boys as well... |
|
|
1 Aug 2011, 05:31 (Ref:2934294) | #14 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 235
|
The top tier, in no particular order, is Hamilton, Button, Alonso, Vettel. They have different strengths and weaknesses, but they're all great drivers who, not coincidentally, have won the World Championship.
|
||
|
1 Aug 2011, 06:10 (Ref:2934306) | #15 | |
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2004
Posts: 2,196
|
Superstars = Vettel, Alonso
A - Graders = Button, Hamilton (when not running into people), Webber, Rosberg, Kobayashi, Di Resta |
|
__________________
"You can get lucky and win one championship but not two ..." Jamie Whincup. I wonder which person with the initials RK he was referring to. |
1 Aug 2011, 07:09 (Ref:2934318) | #16 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2003
Posts: 2,525
|
I believe Button, like a few other drivers, needs things to fall into place to get a great result more so than the likes of Hamilton, Alonso and Vettel. As likable as he is I still see him in that second tier of drivers.
|
||
__________________
ยินดีที่ได้รู้จัก |
1 Aug 2011, 08:14 (Ref:2934345) | #17 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 2,306
|
I personally would put it like this
Alonso Hamilton Vettel (not been in a properly slow car) Button The rest |
||
|
1 Aug 2011, 09:07 (Ref:2934371) | #18 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 961
|
On out-and-out dry pace - Hamilton, Vettel, Alonso at the moment.
Button for me is like the perfect Number 2 - not fast enough in the dry to match Hamilton (2-3 tenths off), but he's a safer pair of hands and brings home meaty points - he's more reliable than Webber and Massa, so I'd easily pick him over those two any time - and he's a lot more marketable too. In slippery conditions he's perhaps the best out there. Sebastian has had a **** car at one point - the T.R at the start of 2008 was pretty average, and I seem to remember him trumping Bourdais (who admittedly was a let-down in F1) and having some great mid-pack races then...before their meteoric rise towards the seasons-end. Di Resta for me looks the real-deal, I imagine one more season with F.I then it's Mercedes GP for him! I'd say Button and Rosberg are a good comparison, but in the latters case, I'd question his overall ability as he's not too hot in the wet/slippery conditions. So, for me: Alonso, Hamilton, Vettel are above the rest - clearly by a good 2 tenths I'd say. Button, Rosberg, Di Resta (potentially) next up Webber (kinda 3rd-tier, almost 2nd...) Kobayashi, Rubens, Perez (potentially), Petrov, Heidfeld, Massa, Schumacher, Sutil, Glock, Heikki - all below that tier Then, well, the rest...and I don't include Ricciardo in that, as no idea how he'll pan-out |
||
__________________
Karting - why are there so many categories!? |
1 Aug 2011, 10:05 (Ref:2934393) | #19 | ||
Racer
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 336
|
Button may not be as outright quick as the 'top three', however he is great at managing his tires and strategy. We've seen him be more aggressive lately in overtaking as well. I think when you consider the all around package Button is one of the best. Vettel, to me, seems like a one trick pony. In fairness dominating from pole is quite a useful skill. So they are just about polar opposites.
Alonso and Hamilton are both well-rounded. I believe they are the best and very close to each other in skill. Hamilton is more mistake prone, but in his rookie season he finished dead even in points with Alonso in the same car. So I would say in general the risks he takes are worth it. Of course, if he could eliminate over-aggression he’d be better off. But, I feel his aggressive style serves him well, all things considered. In Hungary he had a spin, two extra stops and a drive-through and still finished fourth, only 48 seconds behind Button, and ahead of Webber—after a 3-wide pass he made look very routine. As far as Webber's concerned; I am biased (I don't like him) but I think I think I can objectively say he's nowhere near the top 3. If you take as much away from Webber as Razzzor does from Button, Webber would be running for one of the back markers already or in Nascar. He is routinely way slower than Vettel and gets beat by other drivers when Vettel dominates. Not to mention his horrendous starts... I would love to see Kobayashi or Kubica in that car. But since Red Bull are now into team orders, they may want to keep him around like Ferrari have kept Massa. |
||
__________________
You must take the compromise to win, or else nothing. That means: you race or you do not. -Ayrton Senna |
1 Aug 2011, 12:26 (Ref:2934481) | #20 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Sep 2004
Posts: 772
|
Quote:
Alonso imho is a bit on top of Hamilton and Vettel still. Vettel has more potential than Hamilton to climb on the same step as Alonso since he seems to have the right mindset for that. Hamilton has a bit too much tendency to overreact to situations and make errors in judgement. |
|||
|
1 Aug 2011, 15:56 (Ref:2934569) | #21 | |||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 9,114
|
Quote:
Quote:
McLaren really do have the best pairing, I think. We can talk about split strategies, but McLaren almost have a split approach to their drivers. One or the other will get the job done very often. |
|||
|
1 Aug 2011, 17:30 (Ref:2934611) | #22 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2007
Posts: 2,306
|
|||
|
1 Aug 2011, 17:30 (Ref:2934612) | #23 | ||
Race Official
20KPINAL
Join Date: Dec 1999
Posts: 21,606
|
I would say Vettel, Teflonso and Hamilton tops... with Button close behind.
|
||
__________________
Show me a man who won't give it to his woman An' I'll show you somebody who will |
1 Aug 2011, 23:29 (Ref:2934772) | #24 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: May 2001
Posts: 5,702
|
Quote:
"Routinely way slower than Vettel"? He had pole position in two of the last three GPs, finished ahead of him in Germany and at Silverstone he could not have been more all over Seb's rear if he was Boy George... Sure, his starts aren't great but he usually makes up for them during the race... And as ever with Red Bull, how could you ever know how much KERS he has to play with at any individual start!? |
||
|
2 Aug 2011, 03:53 (Ref:2934816) | #25 | |||
Racer
Join Date: May 2009
Posts: 336
|
Quote:
As I said, I don't really like the guy. And as opposed to Schumacher (of old, at least) I don't rate him very highly as a F1 driver. I honestly don't see how anyone rates him anywhere near the top drivers. |
|||
__________________
You must take the compromise to win, or else nothing. That means: you race or you do not. -Ayrton Senna |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Closed Top or Open Top Prototypes? | mattcat | Sportscar & GT Racing | 31 | 20 May 2008 08:47 |
The Top Ten Tin Top Roll. | Mattracer | Australasian Touring Cars. | 19 | 6 Jan 2004 03:32 |
#poll# Top tin top driver outside BTCC | stinger | National & Club Racing | 18 | 29 Sep 2002 10:23 |
Top Unemployed Tin-Top Drivers | Greg Murray | Touring Car Racing | 32 | 9 Apr 2002 11:37 |