[Official] Rate the Grand Prix: Monaco Grand Prix 2024

[Born Racer]

What score do you go for?

[AndrewCherry]

I couldn't quite bring myself to give it a 1, because the discussion between Davidson and Button about the Perez/Magnussen incident was actually quite interesting, two racers giving quite candid reactions. The rest of it was a complete waste of time. Yes, well done to Leclerc, nice to see him achieve that dream, but nice is not the same as fun.


They really do need to do something about Monaco, because aside from the spectacle of the environment, the race itself is devoid of any interest outside of accidents and safety interventions. Not sure whether I agree with the Hamilton suggestion of mandatory pit stops, but either come up with something new or just pack it in.

[Greem]

7. I enjoyed that. There was a lot of jeopardy with the different tactics.

[chillibowl]

3. Looked set to become very interesting but no one really took any chances. Can’t blame them I suppose but far too conservative in terms of strategy.

[Richard C]

I gave it a three. Outside of the drama on lap one, I would have given it a one or maybe a two.

Richard

[BTCC frog]

Originally Posted by Richard C

I gave it a three. Outside of the drama on lap one, I would have given it a one or maybe a two.

Richard

The lap one drama is what ruined the race because they could drive round without pitting. Normally I really enjoy the strategy of Monaco but today there was none. It would have been nice if McLaren had tried something when they had the chance but alas no.

The lap chart will show a flat line for the entire top ten for the entire Grand Prix.

But it is a great result for the championship.

[bjohnsonsmith]

Shame the red flag ruined the mandatory tyre stops. 4 because it was Monaco, otherwise 3.

[GT6]

Sorry but that was not a race, 1 from me

[Aysedasi]

1 from me too. Yes it was nice to see Leclerc win his home race at last, but anything more than a 1 for something that very clearly wasn't motor racing is completely unjustifiable.

[V8 Fireworks]

Originally Posted by Aysedasi

1 from me too. Yes it was nice to see Leclerc win his home race at last, but anything more than a 1 for something that very clearly wasn't motor racing is completely unjustifiable.

Of course it was motor racing. There were a number of racing incidents, and a mistake like running off and cutting the chicane would have let the car behind past. There even were overtakes by the likes of Stroll.

The idea of going slowly enough to prevent a pitstop window, or Alonso driving slowly enough to create a pitstop window for Stroll, is precisely a motor racing tactic too.

Leclerc himself was exasperated that he could not go slower as instructed as he would then "need to push in the low speed" (to protect from being overtaken by Piastri) which in his mind increased risk compared to the pace he was comfortable to slow down to, without the gap getting too small and risky in the slow sections of the track and traction zones.

So Leclerc was comfortable to drive +3s or +4s off the pace, but Ferrari's instruction to match Russell's pace and slow to +5s or +6s was too much in Leclerc's opinion and would have put him at risk from Piastri in his opinion. Very much a case of fascinating motor racing tactics!

[Aysedasi]

Originally Posted by V8 Fireworks

Of course it was motor racing. There were a number of racing incidents, and a mistake like running off and cutting the chicane would have let the car behind past. There even were overtakes by the likes of Stroll.

The idea of going slowly enough to prevent a pitstop window, or Alonso driving slowly enough to create a pitstop window for Stroll, is precisely a motor racing tactic too.

Leclerc himself was exasperated that he could not go slower as instructed as he would then "need to push in the low speed" (to protect from being overtaken by Piastri) which in his mind increased risk compared to the pace he was comfortable to slow down to, without the gap getting too small and risky in the slow sections of the track and traction zones.

So Leclerc was comfortable to drive +3s or +4s off the pace, but Ferrari's instruction to match Russell's pace and slow to +5s or +6s was too much in Leclerc's opinion and would have put him at risk from Piastri in his opinion. Very much a case of fascinating motor racing tactics!

Nope. It may have been 'motor' something, but even the most generous of observers couldn't describe that as 'racing'. I'm glad though that you found it fascinating. I suspect that you may well have been in a fairly small minority holding that view....

[steve_r]

3, and that include a bonus point for McLaren livery.

They need to do something different with the race format around here.

Pretty but Dull.

[chillibowl]

It was a nice livery indeed! Hopefully we get to see it again…maybe Brazil!

[pavloslepaul]

Though to properly rate this GP. Even for Monaco standards it was low, maybe it would in more time give it more reason to revise my view on race. Definitely feeders showed that circuit still have potential for fun racing, so maybe one day regs change would help Monaco.

[TrapezeArtist]

I found it difficult to decide on a rating but gave it a 4. Qualifying was very exciting and lifted my score a bit. If you are a fan of banger racing, the first lap was quite good but really the race itself was an utter snorefest. You have to look all the way down to 11th to find a driver who didn't finish in his grid position.

[morninggents]

Originally Posted by TrapezeArtist

I found it difficult to decide on a rating but gave it a 4. Qualifying was very exciting and lifted my score a bit. If you are a fan of banger racing, the first lap was quite good but really the race itself was an utter snorefest. You have to look all the way down to 11th to find a driver who didn't finish in his grid position.

Pretty much my view too. I gave it a 5. Pleased for Leclerc. Sainz rode his luck.
I saw the Checo/Kmag shunt as 50/50.
A shame the race was mostly a borefest particularly with Max so far back it could have been more exciting.

Generally the cars are too big now, particularly for Monaco.

[Badlands99]

A 2 from me as qualifying was entertaining.
The lap one shunt? Mmmmmmm ...... Checo definitely knew Kmag was there and could have given a bit of room ...... Maybe he is learning from Max!

[chillibowl]

I’m afraid to look and see who gave it a 10!

A joke vote, on the basis of it strictly being a different winner, something truely special that the rest of us are missing? Actually curious.

[Skam85]

I wonder if Michael Masi would have told Toto that "this is a motor race Toto, we went car racing" this week

[VIVA GT]

I don't very often vote in these polls, but decided to make an exception this week, and I gave in an (average) 5. To me the Grand Prix isn't just the race on Sunday, it's the whole weekend which includes qualifying. I thought qualifying was fantastic, edge of the seat stuff whereas the race itself wasn't. (Having said that I still enjoyed the tactical side of things on Sunday too. I'm now thinking that my 5 was maybe a bit harsh and that maybe a 7 would have been more realistic...)

[Aysedasi]

Originally Posted by VIVA GT

I'm now thinking that my 5 was maybe a bit harsh and that maybe a 7 would have been more realistic...)

[VIVA GT]

Originally Posted by Aysedasi

You can quote just the final sentence if you want, just for dramatic effect, but it was meant in summary of my whole post.

[Aysedasi]

Originally Posted by VIVA GT

You can quote just the final sentence if you want, just for dramatic effect, but it was meant in summary of my whole post.

Fair comment. For me, I personally give the score for the race, not for qually. If I included both, my '1' would have been increased to maybe a '3'. Qually was entertaining, but then it usually is. But even the most enthralling qualification session I could possibly imagine (which this one wasn't - to me) wouldn't have made more much in the way of inroads for my rate the GP score.

[S griffin]

Gave it a disappointing 3. All the usual thrills and spills of Monaco happened on the first lap. After that all the overtaking happened down the field. Still it was interesting to have drivers have free will of whether to pit or not

[S griffin]

Forgot to mention the other good thing about this race. Leclerc finally ending his home GP jinx