[Official] Rate the race: Chinese Grand Prix

[Born Racer]

What score do you give for the Grand Prix?

[Teretonga]

I gave it a six.
It was always going to be a let down after Bahrain but they come only occasionally.
However there was little movement in the whole race, and while it promised more, none of it happened.

[Inigo Montoya]

I went with 7, simply for the incredible drives by Hamilton and Alonso. I also really enjoyed the enthusiasm of the crowd!

[chillibowl]

5 for me. thoroughly average but it must be said that average isnt the same as saying bad.

[mikuni]

As the race was running, I decided I would give it a 4 due to the stagnated nature of it. However, as it progressed and I looked more at what was happening, it clawed back a couple of points. Alonso with a fantastic drive, almost able to hang onto second, Ricciardo beating Vettel on merit (despite what Sebastian may say), and a few other interesting little tussles down the field.

Added to that, I like that the "new" teams are starting to play a bit more with the big boys, and Kobayashi's overtake of Vettel was just hilarious.

I should knock a point off for the premature flag wave, but it didn't affect it too much. Had Ricciardo caught Alonso and passed him on the last lap, I'd say RBR would be heading back towards the court of appeal to try and retain another podium for poor old Dan

[Knowlesy]

Decent race, although tailed off from about lap 40. A 6.

[Aysedasi]

6. OK, but a disappointment after Bahrain. Would have been 5 but for Ricciardo stuffing the Tough Luck Kid.......

[Beryl]

Gave it a 4, though thinking now perhaps a 5 would have been more appropriate. Bit of a let down after the drama and action of Bahrain and previous Chinese GPs.

[Bononi]

6. Not so good as it should be, but not that bad.

[Zico]

Originally Posted by Bononi

6. Not so good as it should be, but not that bad.

A 6 for me too, but I'd change the "should" to 'could'.

[bjohnsonsmith]

Bahrain was always going to be a hard act to follow, after China and I was hoping for something to materialise, through the Chinese smog; some intersting tyre stops. 5.

[F1Pete]

3.

[Neil22]

5. Fell asleep during the broadcast and wanted to again during the replay later in the morning. Started nodding when the Williams Team screwed the pooch.

[MagnetON]

1 - I fell asleep almost.

Interestingly I think there was only something like 1 or 2 yellow flags during the whole race. Only GP I can remember that had fewer was the "Tyregate" US GP at Indy which had 1 yellow at the first corner.

[davyboy]

Originally Posted by MagnetON

1 - I fell asleep almost.

Agreed. I would have given it 0 if that was available. An absolute bore-fest that demonstrated Bahrain was sadly a one off

To those who give these kinds of races 6s, 7s and 8s... may I suggest you take a visit to your local kart track to see what wheel to wheel racing actually is !

[JamesH]

Originally Posted by davyboy

Agreed. I would have given it 0 if that was available. An absolute bore-fest that demonstrated Bahrain was sadly a one off

To those who give these kinds of races 6s, 7s and 8s... may I suggest you take a visit to your local kart track to see what wheel to wheel racing actually is !

I think you should probably wait for the end of season before saying Bahrain was a one-off. Still many races to go, and it NR get a decent start and stays with LH, we may get another thriller.

[MarkG]

Originally Posted by davyboy

Agreed. I would have given it 0 if that was available. An absolute bore-fest that demonstrated Bahrain was sadly a one off

To those who give these kinds of races 6s, 7s and 8s... may I suggest you take a visit to your local kart track to see what wheel to wheel racing actually is !

I'm assuming you're talking about short-circuit kart racing, but I would think everyone who has an interest in motorsport knows what kart racing is all about.
To prefer kart racing is one thing, but to be disappointed and even bored if some long circuit car racing doesn't emulate karting, whether it be F1 or anything else, is hard for me to understand to be quite frank.

[davyboy]

Originally Posted by MarkG

I'm assuming you're talking about short-circuit kart racing, but I would think everyone who has an interest in motorsport knows what kart racing is all about.
To prefer kart racing is one thing, but to be disappointed and even bored if some long circuit car racing doesn't emulate karting, whether it be F1 or anything else, is hard for me to understand to be quite frank.

I guess my point is - to warrant a decent rating I would like to see a decent, entertaining race. With the exception of the first few corners, last Sunday was a 56 lap procession. That's why I - and many others - were bored with it.

[Inigo Montoya]

Originally Posted by davyboy

Agreed. I would have given it 0 if that was available. An absolute bore-fest that demonstrated Bahrain was sadly a one off

To those who give these kinds of races 6s, 7s and 8s... may I suggest you take a visit to your local kart track to see what wheel to wheel racing actually is !

And yet, there continues to be an F1 forum with many posts. Different strokes for different folks I guess.

[Adam43]

Originally Posted by davyboy

Agreed. I would have given it 0 if that was available. An absolute bore-fest that demonstrated Bahrain was sadly a one off

To those who give these kinds of races 6s, 7s and 8s... may I suggest you take a visit to your local kart track to see what wheel to wheel racing actually is !

I thought it was better than the majority of races run since 1950. Both for racing and for interest of the machinery. Hence a six.

You do know that a sign of madness is to keep doing something again and again and expecting it to be different.

I like my local kart track and club racing, BTW. Not sure it should replace F1 though. I chose six in full knowledge of these forms of racing.

[davyboy]

Originally Posted by Adam43

You do know that a sign of madness is to keep doing something again and again and expecting it to be different.

Well, Bahrain was different. But you're right... expecting an F1 race to be something other than what it's been for many decades is probably a sign of madness

Anyway, the men with white coats have arrived... so I'm off for the day. Before I leave, can I preset my race rankings for the rest of the season ? I want to give every race a 10.

[steve_r]

6 - Not a classic by any means, but it was the Red Bull mini drama that enlivened it a little towards the end.

[stripedcat]

Originally Posted by steve_r

6 - Not a classic by any means, but it was the Red Bull mini drama that enlivened it a little towards the end.

Good to see that I wasn't the only one who found that entertaining. IT did liven things up.

I'd go with a 6 as well. I suppose it was a bit of letdown compared to Bahrain - but we couldn't expect a repeat of that because it sort of relied on Hamilton and Rosberg qualifying 1 and 2. Seeing Alonso and Rosberg battle to get on the podium did provide some entertainment. There were some pretty decent overtakes in the race. Not a classic - but not a snoozefest either.

[wnut]

4 minus.

[GT6]

Had to listen to it in a hotel in silverstone on the radio, started off exciting but got bored quick,, gave it a 4