|
||||||||||||
|
||||||||||||
|
View Poll Results: Should Circuit Cameras delay a response to Observer's request to stop (or SC) a race? | |||
No. | 17 | 38.64% | |
Yes. | 3 | 6.82% | |
Possibly - it depends on the circumstances | 24 | 54.55% | |
Voters: 44. You may not vote on this poll |
|
Thread Tools | Display Modes |
13 Apr 2012, 12:28 (Ref:3058342) | #1 | ||
Pie On 'ere
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 1,650
|
Who makes the decision?
Circuit cameras seem to be under fire from Observers who are getting 'upset' because of the delay in calling a Race Stop or Safety Car, while Race Control view the video footage in order to confirm or overrule the Observer's decision.
The question is, like the blue flags at Grands Prix, is technology moving all the decision-making to RC? And is this a good thing? Last edited by numbersix; 13 Apr 2012 at 12:48. |
||
__________________
Why is there no such thing as cat-flavored dog food? |
13 Apr 2012, 12:51 (Ref:3058361) | #2 | |
CCNA
Royalridge Computing A LARGE Teapot Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 10,691
|
Well in fairness, those decisions have always been made in the tower - and let's be honest, we all know that with certain clubs or at certain events, you can be pretty sure you'll be overruled.
As always, it really depends on the relationship the marshals have with race control. We had the same issue at Mondello when the cameras first went in - however, it was quickly determined that cameras do not show everything and after a couple of near misses, things settled down a bit. You'll always get people in the tower who think they know better than the trackside marshals. It was going on before cameras and it still happens now. Even with flags. I won't go into detail as I'll only get in trouble, but I have heard some absolute howlers coming over the radio at some circuits with flagging instructions that are either totally unnecessary or are actually wrong! At the end of the day, if organisers delay or refuse a stop and something bad happens, it's them that winds up in the Coroner's court explaining why they totally disregarded the advice of the Marshals on scene. It's harsh, but it's simply the reality. Do I approve - probably not. Can anything be done about it? Nope. They're very handy for verifying race reports and stuff though. |
|
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire. |
13 Apr 2012, 13:01 (Ref:3058365) | #3 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2008
Posts: 2,020
|
Quote:
As mentioned in other threads, flag marshals make the blue flag/light decisions at the GP. RC do not make those decisions. Other decisions, such as stops, SCs, dispatching rescue vehicles have *always* been made in race control. There is no such thing as "overruling" a PC. Before cameras, RC had to go solely on what the PC reports and suggests to make a decision. Spend some time in RC, and you will discover that there are inconsistencies in what different PC's report and ask for. Video footage is just an extra source of information for clerks to go on. You will find that clerks have an idea of how much the opinion/interpretation of differing PCs is aligned with their own, and 'trust' some more than others. PC's generally look at things just from the safety aspect, and take a cautious approach. Clerks, I expect, are more likely to take other factors into account, but at the end of the day, since it is their responsibility, it is their decision. |
|||
__________________
"Sometimes, I just want to tell them 'it's not a race!'" - Guinness2702 |
13 Apr 2012, 13:05 (Ref:3058368) | #4 | ||
La Grande Théière
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2002
Posts: 2,420
|
CCTV watching
I've learned to live with it. Worked with the spy above me for years.
The worst I can say is Clerks that you don't work with on a regular basis can be trying. At best those whose trust you have built up won't question most decisions. It can be annoying and demotivating that every call you make can be met with "the Clerk is looking at it on the screen" but I've come round to fact that the final decision is theirs. (However I may rant a bit after a few of these..) I guess it helps to remember that your decisions are recommendations rather than demands for most things. OTOH - I've called for a red/ rescue unit for a very heavy F3 hit into the wall, to be told that on screen the car is'nt in the wall and all looks normal for a car in the gravel. They'd zoomed in on one of the cars involved and had'nt seen there was another. Point is cameras have failings too. But like EP says tho', no point in *****ing about those bad days - all you end up getting is a phone call or an email saying "somebody tells me says you've said xyz on 10ths" Last edited by Bodysnatcher; 13 Apr 2012 at 13:10. Reason: btw not voting , poll far too simplistic |
||
__________________
Alasdair |
13 Apr 2012, 13:38 (Ref:3058385) | #5 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 3,697
|
Observers are the 'eyes and ears' of the Clerk of the Course, no more no less
I value your opinions, and your judgements but the buck stop with............. Remember there are other factors to consider: time/distance/television et al in no particular order |
||
__________________
Comments made are personal and don't reflect any club or Motorsport UK policy. "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former." - Albert Einstein |
13 Apr 2012, 13:56 (Ref:3058395) | #6 | ||
Pie On 'ere
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2005
Posts: 1,650
|
I just wanted to get a broader picture. Personally I have no issue with RC making decisions because I know and understand they have the final responsibility and I don't take it personally.
If I call a race stop, and a delay by RC causes a crisis on track, then the phlegmatic part of me says, "I called a stop, ain't my problem no more." On the other hand my personal desire to avoid anyone getting hurt will cause me to scream many unrepeatable expletives in the direction of head office! |
||
__________________
Why is there no such thing as cat-flavored dog food? |
13 Apr 2012, 14:05 (Ref:3058400) | #7 | ||
CCNA
Royalridge Computing A LARGE Teapot Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2001
Posts: 10,691
|
Quote:
|
||
__________________
If you feel that the circuit is not safe for racing, please go into the pits and retire. |
13 Apr 2012, 14:31 (Ref:3058424) | #8 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Jun 2011
Posts: 157
|
The over-riding concern must be "Is human life in immediate danger". If that is so then there can be no argument or decision that can over-ride a request for a race stop.
|
||
__________________
Marshalling is like wetting yourself whilst wearing dark trousers. You get a nice warm feeling but no-one notices |
13 Apr 2012, 15:10 (Ref:3058458) | #9 | |||
Rookie
Join Date: Oct 2011
Posts: 94
|
Quote:
In that instance i feel the circuit cameras helped him come to his conclusion. But hey as 'The Fat Clerk' says it's his sphericals on the line,not mine. |
|||
__________________
No matter how fast you think your race car is, if you look at it long enough ... a fly will come and land on it. |
13 Apr 2012, 20:57 (Ref:3058596) | #10 | ||
Rookie
Join Date: Mar 2012
Posts: 99
|
After working in RC over the years doing various different duties I have worked with a lot of different Clerks. This has helped me to learn how each one operates; believe it or not they don't all work in the same way. For example, I know one Clerk who often will not use the cameras. He believes that if a PC asks for a red flag, likewise a SC, they will get it - so one point from this is make sure you need it before you ask for it! You don't know which Clerk is clerking which races.
Another Clerk that I have worked with will consider who is reporting it, as much as I hate to say it, there are some very good PC's and some, well, not so good ones. <-- Make what you will of that! I have experienced a call to RC from a PC asking for a red when a car had spun and managed to park it with two wheels in the gravel. Did the Clerk use the camera? Yes. Did he ask who the PC was? Yes. Did this reflect his decision? Yes. Was he right to let it do so? I think so. Talking from a different perspective however, I have been in a situation where there was quite a serious incident at the Silverstone Classic meeting last year with the E-Type race. A car had spun on the artificial grass, spinning back onto the racing line he was collected by another car with a fair old whack! A hard enough whack that the front left quarter of the car had been ripped away and flung onto the track leaving the to e-types on the run off. Yellows were out (frantically waved may I add), marshals were trackside and cars were still overtaking, running wide and basically not responding to the flag signals. The PC and IO had both asked for a red flag - did they get it? No! Why? The clerk was using the cameras - he could only look at the incident itself and not what was happening around it. There were many comments from the incident team saying they felt unsafe and it was ridiculous that they had to clear it up whilst the car were literally still racing. I have no idea who was clerking that race. Finally, I will say, unfortunately that more and more Clerks are going by what they want to happen and not listening to the PC's i.e. the eyes and ears and more and more Clerks aren't following the correct procedures. It also concerns me that I know more about the "blue book" than some Clerks - I don't even own a copy! |
||
__________________
Luke Souch BRSCC Midlands (Probationary Clerk of the Course/Chief Observer/Race Comms) Silverstone Marshals Team (Specialist/Anything!) |
13 Apr 2012, 21:24 (Ref:3058609) | #11 | |||
Racer
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 237
|
Quote:
|
|||
__________________
Anyone who thinks they can design an attraction and be a success in this city, without serving beer or liquor needs their head examined. - August "Gussie" Busch Jr. (Why Walt Disney World is not in St Louis) |
14 Apr 2012, 10:00 (Ref:3058815) | #12 | ||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2002
Posts: 12,454
|
If you feel unsafe you have to take the decision to remove yourself from trackside. Hopefully under the instructions of the I/O, but you can still advise him why you're leaving. It's not a common occurrence, but I have done it when the actions of the other drivers compromised safety. At that point there is no option but to neutralise the race. We also requested that the message got back to the other drivers why they were halted.
|
||
__________________
Bill Bryson: It is no longer permitted to be stupid and slow. You must choose one or the other. |
15 Apr 2012, 14:28 (Ref:3059557) | #13 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jan 2003
Posts: 6,124
|
I had 3 red flags at Donington yesterday - none actually called for by me! Not disputing the actions at all but IMO we weren't given time to see what the marshals could do once at the scene. I also asked for a fire tender to attend one incident..........still waiting!
|
||
__________________
27 Years In Orange |
15 Apr 2012, 15:22 (Ref:3059596) | #14 | |||
Racer
Join Date: Nov 2003
Posts: 391
|
Quote:
|
|||
|
15 Apr 2012, 20:45 (Ref:3059853) | #15 | ||
Race Official
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2001
Posts: 4,700
|
|||
__________________
DDMC Rescue Crew, Post Chief & Flag Marshal |
16 Apr 2012, 07:50 (Ref:3060037) | #16 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2004
Posts: 3,697
|
Quote:
|
|||
__________________
Comments made are personal and don't reflect any club or Motorsport UK policy. "Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I'm not sure about the former." - Albert Einstein |
16 Apr 2012, 09:16 (Ref:3060079) | #17 | ||
#WhatAreHashTags
Veteran
Join Date: Oct 2003
Posts: 2,526
|
I totally agree with The Fat Clerk - we're all 'marshals' at the end of the day - we just do different jobs and anything that prevents an 'us and them culture' should be encouraged.
|
||
__________________
John Smith Clerk of the Course and MSA Steward Race Director for 360MRC |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Gibernau's decision | X-ecutioner | Bike Racing | 5 | 20 Sep 2004 11:56 |
Poor Decision? | nippy | Marshals Forum | 36 | 28 Jan 2004 14:43 |
New Car Decision | Amaroo Park | Road Car Forum | 48 | 31 Aug 2002 05:13 |