|
||||||||||
|
||||||||||
9 Feb 2005, 17:16 (Ref:1221111) | #1 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 8,125
|
Getting Rid of Mandatory Stops?
Quote:
Last edited by macdaddy; 9 Feb 2005 at 17:17. |
|||
__________________
Don't make a fuss, just get on the bus! |
9 Feb 2005, 17:42 (Ref:1221134) | #2 | |
Registered User
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 16,661
|
I 100% agree with him.
If you can manage your fuel to go non-stop for the whole race good luck to you! If the organisers can keep needless full-course yellow periods to a minimum, together with rules that let competitors pit as and when they wish, that will be a major positive. |
|
|
9 Feb 2005, 18:29 (Ref:1221187) | #3 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,065
|
I always thought that fuel management is part of the strategy when you race. Having mandatory pit windows basically takes that element away. Although I understand that CC probably wants to keep everyone equal, but this isn't a way to do it. I am sure that we have seen many F1 races where pit strategy has won races.
And besides, Champ Cars can only go so many laps before refuleing anyways, so why in the heck do you need a rule saying that you have to pit at a certain lap mumber... especially when the cars need to refuel at that pit window point anyways? It makes no sense to me. |
||
__________________
Cuz trucks need love, too! |
9 Feb 2005, 18:31 (Ref:1221188) | #4 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 8,125
|
There's more on TSN:
Quote:
And... closing the pits basically mandates green-flag stops, but approaches it from a new angle. I think it's all good. |
|||
__________________
Don't make a fuss, just get on the bus! |
9 Feb 2005, 18:37 (Ref:1221196) | #5 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,065
|
From what it sounds like it should make for better racing. But now theres the problem of attrition. What if there is a race where there is an incident on the 30th lap where the cars need to pit soon, and the pits are closed? Then you'll see like a fourth of the field pull over because of running out of gas.
|
||
__________________
Cuz trucks need love, too! |
9 Feb 2005, 18:48 (Ref:1221206) | #6 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,744
|
I didn't know what to think of this either. Closing the pits under yellow has problems as outlined above, but it would definately remove virtually all pure fuel runs.
In my mind the worst scenerio is where everyone is cruising around @ 90% because they're trying to save fuel. That stinks. Even the old fuel nob was better because the driver would still do everything they could to go fast (usually), they just had less power. I didn't see anything in that article that suggests how to remove that problem. Last edited by Snrub; 9 Feb 2005 at 18:49. |
||
__________________
No Rotor, No Motor. |
9 Feb 2005, 19:36 (Ref:1221244) | #7 | |
Registered User
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 16,661
|
When the pits are "closed" there's nothing physically stopping you from coming in, but you'd get a stop-go once it goes green.
So no-one will run out of fuel. And on Snrub's point - if "everyone" was cruising around trying to save fuel, at least one driver would get wise to it and up his pace - someone would have nothing to lose by going for it. So we would see excitement. |
|
|
9 Feb 2005, 21:00 (Ref:1221345) | #8 | ||
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 343
|
Does anyone know if Champ Car mandates certain fuel tank sizes at different tracks? This would be another way to manage a race and the number of stops required.
|
||
|
9 Feb 2005, 22:10 (Ref:1221395) | #9 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,065
|
Quote:
|
|||
__________________
Cuz trucks need love, too! |
9 Feb 2005, 22:54 (Ref:1221442) | #10 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,065
|
BTW, I am glad that this topic was brought up because ever since they were in the rules mandatory pit stops really have ****ed me off. I hope that we can find some solutions and *maybe* CC will listen to us!
Cheers, macdaddy |
||
__________________
Cuz trucks need love, too! |
10 Feb 2005, 03:33 (Ref:1221585) | #11 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 5,073
|
Anything that promotes racing and on-track action is a good thing. I was never able to figure out what the "pit window" thing was supposed to accomplish.
More importantly they have realized this and eliminated it. |
||
__________________
"He's still a young guy and I always think, slightly morbidly, the last thing you learn is how to die and at the end of the day everybody learns every single day." - The Ever-Cheerfull Ron Dennis on Lewis Hamilton. |
10 Feb 2005, 05:18 (Ref:1221614) | #12 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 8,125
|
Y'all probably know that I'm not overly-aware of any form of motorsport outside CART/ChampCar. And thus I ask this question: Would "we" become the first major series to close the pits under yellow? Is this uncharted territory?
|
||
__________________
Don't make a fuss, just get on the bus! |
10 Feb 2005, 08:28 (Ref:1221696) | #13 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2004
Posts: 1,065
|
NASCAR kind of closes the pits under yellow flags, but not for the entire period. I have observed that they open them after a couple of caution laps. Then they let those who are on the lead lap pit first, followed by everyone else.
|
||
__________________
Cuz trucks need love, too! |
10 Feb 2005, 16:34 (Ref:1222107) | #14 | |||
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2003
Posts: 343
|
Quote:
|
|||
|
10 Feb 2005, 17:19 (Ref:1222143) | #15 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Nov 2002
Posts: 4,744
|
Champ Car has closed the pits under yellows, but never for the whole yellow, I think CC might be the first as Macdaddy suggested.
If you're going to run out of fuel and you run into the pits when you're not allowed to because you were going to run out of fuel, how do they adjust for that? Do you get a penalty? How do they know that you were being honest? What if you were lying and just wanted to fill up on the yellow? As for teams/drivers taking advantage of everyone running @ 90%, I'm exagerating slightly, but we have had that scenerio play out a number of times. Take this imaginary situation, a fuel load lasts 35 laps and time it takes in pitlane to fill up and go in/out is 40 seconds. Driver #1 drives 1 second a lap slower than he is capable of, acheives 37 laps on his fuel and has to do one fewer stop. Driver #2 drives at his normal pace which is 1 second a lap faster than Driver #1's slow pace and acheives 35 laps on his fuel but has to do an extra stop. Driver #2 would finish behind driver #1. Not only that, but if driver #2 will likely have difficulty passing other drivers lapping at Driver #1's pace and his lap times are going to be seriously compromised. Obviously Driver #1 will come out ahead. Often it's not that simple, but it's simply that they cannot easily get by a car that is infront of them. The solution is to save fuel to: 1. Last an extra lap and get out ahead of the guy in front. 2. Hope for a yellow that you can take advantage of, but you competitors may not be able to take advantage of. 3. Use the extra fuel to run fast laps once the slower car has moved out of your way in the hopes of catching other competitors. Last edited by Snrub; 10 Feb 2005 at 17:20. |
||
__________________
No Rotor, No Motor. |
10 Feb 2005, 17:48 (Ref:1222165) | #16 | ||||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 8,125
|
Quote:
Quote:
|
||||
__________________
Don't make a fuss, just get on the bus! |
10 Feb 2005, 18:14 (Ref:1222192) | #17 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 5,073
|
The bottom line is that the tension created over pit stop strategy will be dictated by the flow of the race and the choices the teams make regarding pace, etc - not an artificial construct like the "pit window" concept was.
No pit windows = a good thing. |
||
__________________
"He's still a young guy and I always think, slightly morbidly, the last thing you learn is how to die and at the end of the day everybody learns every single day." - The Ever-Cheerfull Ron Dennis on Lewis Hamilton. |
10 Feb 2005, 18:18 (Ref:1222194) | #18 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Apr 2004
Posts: 865
|
Someone mentioned something about the overusage of full course yellows....
Sometimes i think a full course yellow is a good way to bring the field back together. I sometimes find a race pointless to watch if the leader is 30 seconds ahead of the field and the second place guy has a good car to pass, but not to catch up with. If the spotters don't want to throw a full course yellow out, then theres probably no likelihood of there being a fight for the finish if the guy is ahead by so much. </off topic> |
||
|
10 Feb 2005, 18:27 (Ref:1222204) | #19 | ||
Registered User
Veteran
Join Date: Feb 2003
Posts: 16,661
|
Quote:
I'm absolutely astonished. If the leader is 30 seconds up the road, it's because he/his team deserve to be! |
||
|
10 Feb 2005, 18:40 (Ref:1222226) | #20 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jun 2001
Posts: 8,125
|
I wonder what else Cotman has up his sleeve when he mentioned,
"The goal is a better show, and more green flag racing." ChampCar made the 2005 Rulebook available some weeks ago, but I've got a feeling that there's gonna be a revised edition before LongBeach. |
||
__________________
Don't make a fuss, just get on the bus! |
10 Feb 2005, 19:36 (Ref:1222302) | #21 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Aug 2004
Posts: 7,263
|
Quote:
But you rarely see Champ Car races won by that kind of distance. Also I actuly, don't find the mandatory pit stops a bad thing. They prevented drivers easing off to preserve fuel therefore uneventful type races. Also winning a race was down to who could go the longest without pitting, and not nesersarly the fastest guy out on the track. As a result of mandatory pit stops, all of this was prevented. Last edited by luke; 10 Feb 2005 at 19:37. |
|||
__________________
The thrill from west hill |
10 Feb 2005, 20:10 (Ref:1222349) | #22 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 5,073
|
No offense, but if one finds it pointless to watch if someone has a big lead isn't that negating the fact that there might be some good racing going on anyway?
I would also agree with K-B that someone being that far ahead is their achievement. For Race Control to throw a Yellow to "bunch things up" would be extremely frustrating to me as a fan and a racer. As a fan, one would hope that the racing is clean and honest. I really don't want the field "bunched-up" just to make it more "exciting." It would be like going to a football match and having the ref start handing out red cards to a team that has a big lead to "even things up." As a racer I would have to ask: "What is the point of optimizing the setup and strategy if someone is going to wipe that out at their discretion?" As far as the mandatory stops eliminating the economy runs I do not think that is entirely true as there are other factors such as tire wear/performance and lap times decreasing as fuel load decreases. In other words over a certain distance you are going to have to come in X number of times for tires anyway, so let the teams decide when they are going to do that rather than impose it on them. My own philosophy here is to give 'em as much ethanol as they want, turn the boost knob to "Ludicrous" and tell them to have at it! Last edited by JohnSSC; 10 Feb 2005 at 20:12. |
||
__________________
"He's still a young guy and I always think, slightly morbidly, the last thing you learn is how to die and at the end of the day everybody learns every single day." - The Ever-Cheerfull Ron Dennis on Lewis Hamilton. |
10 Feb 2005, 20:17 (Ref:1222362) | #23 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Jul 2002
Posts: 5,073
|
A further note on those famous Caution Flags for "debris" that NASCAR loves to throw: that is a big reason why I stopped watching NASCAR. They do this all the time to "keep it close." To my way of thinking this was simple manipulation of the result. The best car/driver did not win because someone else might have been slightly better on the restarts while the guy who was too far ahead had demonstrated superiority in every other facet: handling traffic, running in clean air, overall handling and pit stop strategy.
When you do these things it stops being racing and becomes WWF. |
||
__________________
"He's still a young guy and I always think, slightly morbidly, the last thing you learn is how to die and at the end of the day everybody learns every single day." - The Ever-Cheerfull Ron Dennis on Lewis Hamilton. |
11 Feb 2005, 23:11 (Ref:1223353) | #24 | |||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,244
|
Quote:
And they would've got away with it too, there WAS a smoking car on the track and everything, but no, things remained green! Champcar doesn't need faux Yellow periods to put on good races! |
|||
__________________
We need to win like you need to breathe.... |
11 Feb 2005, 23:19 (Ref:1223360) | #25 | ||
Veteran
Join Date: Mar 2003
Posts: 1,244
|
.....errrr.....getting on to the topic (at last! ) I too am glad that this issue has been raised.
We need SOME form of rules that stop teams telling their drivers to conserve fuel......or at least HALF of the drivers to conserve fuel and the other half to go for it.....but even if it's just having a word with the teams saying "guys, economy runs suck, please at least let your guys run flat out...." One of the benifits if Champcar were less gun-shy with the Yellows is at least it would change peoples strategy somewhat.... As for the fact that the "newbie" in charge is even raising this issue....well, I like him already! |
||
__________________
We need to win like you need to breathe.... |
|
|
Similar Threads | ||||
Thread | Thread Starter | Forum | Replies | Last Post |
Mandatory Pit Window | macdaddy | ChampCar World Series | 12 | 18 Apr 2003 20:22 |
Should Friday Testing be mandatory? | Wrex | Formula One | 5 | 15 Apr 2003 17:11 |
Cart to dump mandatory pit window ? | Jay | ChampCar World Series | 22 | 3 Apr 2003 03:47 |